I went shopping on ELF.com to get a few items that I love that I just can’t find in stores. So I was there I decided to give these eyeliner pens another shot. I did an earlier review on this product already here. So I bought three of these pens in Coffee, Teal, Black.
ELF Claims: Smudge free, no budge eyeliner that lasts for hours. Smooth pen applicator easily glides on color for very fine to bold lines. Waterproof.
What I found:
|Top to Bottom: Coffee, Teal, Black|
- Super easy to apply
- The tip retains it shape even after a lot of use.
- Lasts super long.
- Color payoff is great
- Matte color
- It’s not waterproof, or pool proof.
The only issue I had with these pens other than them not being waterproof is that the Teal color comes up super dark on my lids when applied. The picture online led me to believe it was lighter, and brighter. It looks bright on my wrist but once applied to my top lashes, it looks extremely dark.
VERDICT: Well I did like these pens a second time around. The one I got must have been a fluke. I actually think that who shipment I got a batch of bad products. So for $1 each you can not go wrong. I will purchase again!