I have to admit when I found out my favorite mascara line is coming out with a gel liner that is suppsed to make wing liner easier, I had to have it. It wasn't a want but a need. With a ton of Birchbox points burning a hole in my pocket I knew I needed to get my hands on it. Click down below to find out what I think about this gel liner pen!
What It promises
Why we love it!
How to apply
What I found:
I didn't like I had to turn eyeliner more than 52 clicks see some product. Ummm did they not fill it properly? What's the deal with that benefit? I did end up asking that on twitter and benefit responded that it was normal.
I have to say I am personally pretty proficient in applying the wing linger look with liquid liner, as well as felt tip, and gel. When I saw the angled tip it made me super excited. I like to apply potted gel liner with an angled brush so this wasn't anything new to me.
With that being said I don't like this liner. Why not you ask? EVERYONE is RAVING about this liner. How is that possible you ask, am I crazy or something? Nope, I promise I'm not. Just listen to see why I personally don't like it.
It doesn't apply smoothly, you heard me. It's not a clean line. It skips, like record. Honestly I can't get a clean line. It peels leaving clumps in my lashes and on my face. Who wants clumpy gel liner in their lashes? I know I don't!
I know, I know apply it slowly Meg! I can hear it now. No. I feel comfortable doing one clean swipe. I rather just use a gel pot liner with an angle brush, I can apply it quickly. This is not for if you are short on time.
My other gripe it doesn't last. I wore it one day to work without any primer or eyeshadow. I worked only a four hour shift (Retail) it smudged on my eyelids, as well as my wing faded. When I pay $20 for an eyeliner I expect it to be able to perform. It claims this eyeliner is waterproof then it should not be smudging after a four hour work shift.
Now if I use primer and eyeshadow this liner stays all day. I wouldn't say it doesn't budge because it will if you rub your eye. It's a really black, liner which I love about it. Nice and dark.
I know a lot of ladies loved this but I don't like that I have to baby this expensive eyeliner when I can buy a $1 ELF liquid liner that last all day without primer to boot. Here's the secret though, I don't need the angled tip to help guide me when I do a winged liner look. It's a novel idea, just does not work for me.
Here's a tip for those who complain on how hard this is to remove. Use baby oil. Comes off instantly no rubbing needed.
- Super dark black liner
- angled tip applicator
- Gel liner skips when applying it
- you have to go slow when applying
- gel liner clumps when applying and falls into the lashes, and onto the face
- must use primer and eyeshadow with this to get this to last
- Can not be worn alone
- You have to twist it up too many times before you even see product, and then takes a lot of clicks during application as well
- Wear time is not there
VERDICT: I'm sorry to say but I really don't like this. It's novel, but not for me. I wouldn't recommend this to others, even those just starting out either. Not worth the aggravation during application. As much as I love the mascara of this line, this eyeliner is a Skip for me.